Word Of Deal To Inspect Iran's Nuclear Program Raises Hopes For Broader Talks
Originally published on Tue May 22, 2012 4:50 pm
A deal has been agreed to that will facilitate international monitors' effort to investigate whether Iran is trying to develop nuclear weapons, the head of the International Atomic Energy Agency told reporters in Vienna earlier today.
The Financial Times puts the news this way:
"Yukiya Amano, director-general of the International Atomic Energy Agency, said on Tuesday that he had reached a deal with Iran on investigating Tehran's suspected nuclear weapons program. The head of the U.N. body said a 'decision was made to conclude and sign the agreement. . . . I can say it will be signed quite soon.' "
As the Los Angeles Times adds, "inspectors have been trying to gain wider access to Iranian atomic facilities." And if this deal is finalized, it would be "the first time since 2007 that Iran, which says its nuclear work is for exclusively peaceful purposes, has accepted wider inspections."
The Financial Times' James Blitz, in an analysis of this news, says that Amano has "always taken a hard-headed approach towards Iran in the three years he has headed the United Nations nuclear watchdog. ... So if Mr. Amano says he is about to sign a deal with Iran under which the regime starts answering those questions that is significant. It suggests that Mr Amano believes Iran will genuinely start to co-operate with the IAEA for the first time in four years – possibly giving access to sites where western intelligence agencies believe weapons work has been done."
Reuters notes that Amano, who had just arrived in Vienna after talks with Iranian officials in Tehran, was "speaking on the eve of the Baghdad meeting where six powers will test Iranian willingness to put transparent limits on its nuclear program," and that "Amano said his wish for access to an Iranian military site where nuclear weapons-relevant tests may have occurred would be addressed as part of the accord."
But the wire service also says "the powers will be wary of past failures to carry out extra inspection deals between the International Atomic Energy Agency and Iran, and Western patience is wearing thin."
The six powers, known as the P5+1 are the five permanent members of the U.N. Security Council — China, France, Russia, the U.K. and the U.S. — and Germany.
Update at 1:15 p.m. ET. Strong Signal?
Analysts say that if Iran has agreed to give IAEA inspectors access to its atomic facilities, that's a signal Iran may be prepared for serious negotiations, NPR's Peter Kenyon will report later today on All Things Considered.
"I think the chances for productive diplomacy are better than they have been probably for the past seven years," George Perkovich, director of the nuclear program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, tells Peter.
Perkovich also says that economic sanctions imposed on Iran "have started to have a significant impact." And he thinks that "the Iranians have accomplished enough in the development of their nuclear capability that they might be able to say, 'okay, we've demonstrated a capability, let's make a deal.' "
Mark Fitzpatrick from the non-proliferation program at London's International Institute for Strategic Studies, tells Peter that the talks starting Wednesday might be able to produce three things:
-- A suspension by Iran of its program to produce 20 percent-enriched uranium, which is closer to weapons-grade than the 3 percent to 5 percent needed to produce nuclear energy.
-- An agreement on what to do with the 20 percent-enriched uranium Iran already has.
-- An agreement to stop work at the underground facility in Fordow, where the 20 percent enrichment has been taking place.
Update at 9:15 a.m. ET. Raising Hopes:
From Istanbul, NPR's Peter Kenyon tells our Newscast Desk that "the apparent breakthrough could raise hopes for further progress at Wednesday's talks. Issues likely to to come up at that meeting include Iran's stockpile of 20 percent-enriched uranium."
AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:
In a surprise announcement today, the head of the U.N.'s nuclear agency says he's close to signing an agreement with Iran. The plan would allow inspectors to asses Iran's nuclear activities. The move comes just one day ahead of talks about that nuclear program between Iran and six world powers. NPR's Peter Kenyon reports that negotiators are cautiously hopeful.
PETER KENYON, BYLINE: There has been some of the usual hard-line bluster in the run-up to the Baghdad talks. Senior Iranian officials are insisting they will never give up their inalienable rights, which include the right to enrich their own uranium. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, meanwhile, dismissed the talks as another opportunity for Iran, in his words, "to deceive and delay, as North Korea did."
But there's also a new strain of optimism boosted by business-like preparatory meetings and signals that Tehran is prepared to move beyond rhetoric and deal with substance.
GEORGE PERKOVICH: Well, I think the chances of productive diplomacy are better than they've been probably in the last seven years.
KENYON: George Perkovich directs the nuclear program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington. He says there are a number of reasons for the positive trend, not least the painful economic sanctions that have been wearing down the Iranian economy, and the threat of even more punitive oil sanctions due to kick in July 1st.
PERKOVICH: Sanctions have started to have a significant impact in Iran. And also, the Iranians have accomplished enough in the development of their nuclear capability that they might be able to say, OK, we've demonstrated a capability, let's make a deal.
KENYON: The delicate question now is whether this more positive atmosphere can lead to confidence-building steps, and then toward a diplomatic agreement to diffuse the crisis. The likely first step will involve Iran's recent focus on enriching uranium to 20 percent, which is much closer to weapons grade than the 3 to 5 percent needed for nuclear energy. There is a medical use for 20 percent enriched uranium, and the West has offered in the past to give Iran that type of fuel if it stops enriching its own.
Mark Fitzpatrick, with the non-proliferation program at the London-based International Institute for Strategic Studies, says from the international point of view, the most that could be hoped for out of the next few discussions is a set of three agreements.
MARK FITZPATRICK: One is the suspension of 20 percent enrichment. Two, doing something with the stockpile, a hundred kilograms or so, of 20 percent enriched uranium. And three, stopping the work at the underground facility at Fordow.
KENYON: Fordow is where Iran built a nuclear facility deep inside a mountain near the holy city of Qom. That's where the 20 percent enrichment is taking place. Fitzpatrick argues that if Iran stops enriching to 20 percent, it will be doing nothing at Fordow, so why keep it open?
But for Iran, the security of its nuclear program is a sensitive issue. Tehran's fears of a potential military strike have been exacerbated by the assassination of several of its nuclear scientists. Overcoming those fears, analysts say, will take time and the kind of effort neither side has seemed willing to put forth to date.
Analyst George Perkovich at Carnegie says for Iran, avoiding the July 1st EU oil sanctions is crucial. And if the Baghdad meeting and a hoped for next meeting in June don't lead to that, the atmosphere could quickly sour.
PERKOVICH: If those sanctions kick in, why would Iran make a deal now? They won't. I think they'd just say, well, hell, if you're going to punish us in any case, then why should I concede anything? So agreeing to suspend those sanctions will be a very important factor for Iran.
KENYON: Officials say that kind of concession on sanctions is very unlikely to come this week in Baghdad. But if Iran continues to move toward a possible agreement, at some point, the West will have to not only drop future sanctions but ease existing ones. And analysts say for Washington that won't be easy, because Congress has written some of the unilateral Iran sanctions in such a way that they will be extremely difficult to undo.
Peter Kenyon, NPR News, Istanbul. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.