Prison Rape Law A Decade Old, But Most States Not In Compliance

Jun 6, 2014
Originally published on June 6, 2014 6:29 pm

The clock is ticking on a decade-long effort to prevent sexual violence inside American prisons. In a recent survey, the vast majority of states said they will try to comply with federal rules. But several others, led by Texas, have protested to the Justice Department.

Jan Lastocy served 15 months in a Michigan prison for attempted embezzlement — her first brush with the law. The assaults began when a new corrections officer showed up at the warehouse where she had been assigned to work as a secretary.

"The first time that I went — it happened with me — I went into the dry goods room and he told me that he knew I was ready because it had been too long and he was going to give me what I had been missing," Lastocy says.

She remembers the guard was standing behind a big plate of cake batter.

"And when I said no, he said, 'Do I have to get my pen out?' So I knew right away what he meant. If I didn't do what he told me, he was gonna write me a ticket," she says.

That ticket could stop her from getting out of the facility and going home to her husband and children in Michigan. So for the next six months, Lastocy suffered in silence, never telling anyone about the rapes.

"Part of the reason I never said anything is because the warden had made the comment that if it ever came down to the word of an inmate versus a guard, she would always believe the guard over the inmate," she says.

Justice Department official Mary Lou Leary, who works with states to stop sexual assault behind bars, calls Lastocy's case "completely appalling."

"It is an anathema to everything the justice system stands for," she says. "They may be inmates, but they are victims, and they need the same respect and care as any other victim of crime."

In 2003, Congress unanimously passed the Prison Rape Elimination Act, designed to educate inmates about their rights and provide them with a way to report crimes. (Lastocy was in prison in 1998, before the law went into effect; Michigan says it will try to comply with federal rules.)

It has taken nearly 11 years for the law, known as PREA, to take hold. A congressional commission spent years studying the problem, and the Justice Department took its time, too. Even after all this time, 46 states say they are still working on complying, and two are in full compliance. Judge Reggie Walton, who led a panel that developed standards for state and federal prisons, says he's troubled by those numbers.

"I feel that when we involuntarily detain people, which I have no problem with doing as far as individuals who commit crime, ... [then] we have an obligation to protect them," he says. "And I think it's very troubling that we don't have further compliance with the standards."

Texas Gov. Rick Perry would beg to differ. Earlier this year, he sent the Justice Department a letter arguing that the federal law on prison rape violates states' rights. Perry, a Republican, adds that it's too expensive and burdensome to follow the federal rules.

Advocates point out that Texas got nearly $4 million in U.S. grants to help fight prison rape. And, they say, Justice Department surveys of inmates suggest facilities in the state have among the highest rates of sexual victimization in the U.S.

Perry's office didn't agree to sit for an interview, but his letter to the Justice Department says Texas has taken steps to reduce prison rape on its own.

For his part, Judge Walton says the courthouse doors should be open for inmates who can't find relief anywhere else.

"Hopefully that will leave [the state] vulnerable to civil damages; maybe that will be an incentive," he says.

Back in Michigan, Lastocy finished her time and went home to her family. Months later, she got a call from investigators asking about the guard who assaulted her and several other women in the prison camp. One of those inmates had saved the guard's DNA and reported it to higher-ups. The guard was convicted and ultimately served five years.

Lastocy says the states need to move faster so no one else has to endure that kind of pain.

"I guess at this point all we can ask is that they try," she says. "But are they going to try a little bit, or are they going to try a lot?"

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Robert Siegel.

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

And I'm Audie Cornish. The clock is ticking on new federal rules imposed to prevent sexual violence inside American prisons. The rules were the result of a decade-long campaign to address such violence. A great majority of states say they'll try to comply with new federal rules. But several, led by Texas, have protested and appealed the rules to the Justice Department. The protesters include many of the states with the highest rates of reported prison rape, in the country. NPR's Carrie Johnson reports.

CARRIE JOHNSON, BYLINE: Jan Lastocy served 15 months for attempted embezzlement, her first brush with the law. The assaults began when a new corrections officer showed up at the warehouse, where she'd been assigned to work as a secretary.

JAN LASTOCY: The first time I went, it happened with me. I went to the dry goods room. And he told me that he knew I was ready because it'd been too long. And that he was going to give me what I was missing.

JOHNSON: Lastocy remembers the guard was standing behind a big palate of cake batter.

LASTOCY: And when I said no, he said, do I have to get my pen out? I knew right away what he meant. If I didn't do what he told me, he was going to write a ticket.

JOHNSON: A ticket that could stop her from getting out of the facility. And going home to her husband and children, in Michigan. So for the next six months, Lastocy suffered in silence, never telling anyone about the rapes.

LASTOCY: And part of the reason I never said anything was because the warden had made the comment that, if it ever came down to the word of an inmate verses a guard, she would always believe the guard over the inmate.

MARY LOU LEARY: That is completely appalling. It's an anathema of everything the justice system stands for.

JOHNSON: That's Mary Lou Leary. She's a Justice Department official, who works with states to stop a sexual assault behind bars.

LEARY: They may be inmates, but they are victims. And they need the same respect and care as any other victim of crime.

JOHNSON: In 2003, Congress unanimously passed the Prison Rape Elimination Act. The law's designed to educate inmates about their rights and provide them with a way to report crime. It's taken nearly 11 years for the law, known as PREA, to take hold. A congressional commission spent years studying the problem. And the Justice Department took its time, too. Even after all this time, 48 states say they're still working on complying. Judge Reggie Walton, who led a panel that develop standards for state and federal prisons, says he's troubled by those numbers.

JUDGE REGGIE WALTON: I feel that, when we involuntarily detain people, which I have no problem with doing, you know, as far as individuals who commit crimes, that we have an obligation to protect them. And I think it's very troubling that we don't have further compliance with the standards.

JOHNSON: Texas Gov. Rick Perry would beg to differ. Earlier this year, Perry sent the Justice Department a letter arguing the federal law on prison rape violates state's rights. Perry, a Republican, adds it's too expensive and burdensome to follow the federal rules. Advocates point out that Texas got nearly $4 million in U.S. grants to help fight prison rape. And that DOJ surveys of inmates suggest facilities, in the state, have among the highest rates of sexual victimization in the U.S. Gov. Perry's office didn't agree to sit for an interview. But his letter says Texas has taken steps to reduce prison rape on its own. For his part, Judge Walton says, the courthouse door should be open for inmates, who can't find relief anywhere else.

WALTON: Hopefully that won't leave them vulnerable to civil damages. Maybe that will be an incentive.

JOHNSON: Back in Michigan, Jan Lastocy finished her time and went home to her family. Sometime later, she got a call from investigators, asking about the guard was assaulted her, and several other women, in the prison camp. One of those inmates saved his DNA and reported it to higher-ups. The guard was convicted and, ultimately, served five years. Lastocy says, the states need to move faster, so no one else has to endure that kind of pain

LASTOCY: I guess, at this point, all we can ask is they try, you know. But are they going to try a little bit or are they going to try a lot?

JOHNSON: Carrie Johnson, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.