Romney Rules Rural As Obama's Support Wanes
Originally published on Tue September 25, 2012 8:08 am
The nation's smallest and most remote places are providing Mitt Romney's biggest margins in battleground states as the 2012 presidential race enters its final weeks.
In fact, rural counties are keeping Romney competitive in the states that are now up for grabs. That's what a new bipartisan survey indicates. The poll also finds that President Obama's rural support has plunged since 2008.
The telephone survey of 600 likely voters in rural counties in nine battleground states was conducted Sept. 15-18. A bipartisan polling team produced the survey for the Center for Rural Strategies, a Kentucky-based group trying to attract attention to rural issues.
The rural voters polled favored Romney by 14 points, giving him 54 percent. They said Romney would do a better job with the economy (54 percent), with rural issues (47 percent) and with sharing their values (52 percent). More than half are comfortable with Romney as commander in chief and with him keeping the nation safe and secure.
President Obama garnered 40 percent, a seven-point dive from rural battleground voting four years ago.
"Rural areas in this country are very tough for President Obama," says Anna Greenberg of Greenberg Quinlan Rosner Research, a polling firm for Democrats. Greenberg conducted the bipartisan poll and provided analysis.
"Obama's lead is opening up primarily in urban and suburban areas," Greenberg says. "It's all the more reason that Mitt Romney needs rural America because it's the only place where he's really strong."
Greenberg's pollsters found a rock-solid Romney supporter in Stevens Point, Wis., when 66-year-old Donald Young answered the phone.
"Romney has a business background," Young tells NPR. That's key for Young because he says he was forced to retire from his painting business when the economy soured.
"Romney will do something to create a friendly business climate, and [businesses] will open up and start hiring and developing," Young adds.
The economy also has a 2008 Obama supporter now ready to vote for Romney.
"I just thought we'd be in a lot better position here in the United States than we are," says 26-year-old Nicole Heeringa, a single mother of two who works in a candy store in Waupun, Wis.
"Not a lot has been done with our economy," Heeringa continues. "I just want the economy to get better."
Republican pollster and political consultant Glen Bolger supervised the rural battleground survey and also provided analysis. He says rural voters are "going back to their more traditional voting patterns."
Republicans were in charge in 2008, Bolger says, and rural voters joined most of the rest of the electorate in saying, " 'We need a change.' Now you've got the Democrats controlling the White House [and] Senate all four years and the House for two years. People are [again] saying, 'Well, that's not working. It's time for a change.' "
The poll indicates that Romney's rural support is weakest among women. Obama polled better than Romney on only one question: Who would do a better job of addressing the needs and concerns of women? The president scored five points better.
Some of the women who said they were committed to Romney admitted to being ambivalent in followup interviews with NPR.
Obama "is just more appealing," says Erin Jordan, a 24-year-old nurse from Gallipolis, Ohio. "Even doing things like going on late-night shows like Jimmy Fallon and doing those little rap things. ... It just makes him more approachable."
When Jordan thinks of Mitt Romney, "I picture my dad," she says. "My dad's not always firm in what he believes in politically, I guess."
But Romney may still get Jordan's vote because, as a nurse, she's troubled about changes in health care under Obama, and she's concerned about more change if he's re-elected.
Still, the volatility encourages Democratic pollster Greenberg.
"I actually think it's possible that Obama picks up more support in rural areas, which will just bolster a growing lead, frankly," she says.
Republican Bolger disagrees.
"This is a really polarized electorate that we've got in 2012. There's not a lot of movement," Bolger says. "I think it's going to be very difficult for the president to chip away at Mitt Romney's big rural advantage."
In fact, there isn't much rural support up for grabs if the new survey reflects reality. Only 2 percent of those surveyed are undecided or noncommittal. Four percent indicated solid support for Libertarian Gary Johnson or another candidate. Only 3 percent were soft or leaning when they said they preferred Romney or Obama.
Romney appears to have the rural margin he needs to be competitive in battleground states. And Obama has failed, it seems, to hold on to enough of the rural voters who helped him become president.
Additional analysis of the survey is available at the Daily Yonder, a rural news service from the Center for Rural Strategies.
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
A lot of surveys show Mitt Romney following behind President Obama. But one survey has good news for the Republican candidate. It gives him a huge and solid lead among a key Republican constituency: rural voters in battleground states. The same survey shows that the President Obama's rural support has eroded since 2008.
Here's NPR's Howard Berkes.
HOWARD BERKES, BYLINE: People and geese flock to Waupun, Wisconsin, the migrating geese because there's prime habitat; people go to see the geese. So far, neither flock includes candidates for president, so single mom Nicole Heeringa is basing her 2012 vote on how life hasn't changed since 2008.
NICOLE HERRINGA: I thought we'd be in a lot better position here in the United States than we are. Not a lot has been done with our economy. I just want the economy to get better, is really all I want.
BERKES: Heeringa is 26 and works in a candy store. She checked the Obama box on her ballot four years ago, when 47 percent of the voters in rural battleground counties did the very same thing. That unusually strong rural showing for a Democrat helped get the president elected, but a new survey from the Center for Rural Strategies has the president seven points lower there now.
GLEN BOLGER: I think you're seeing two things happening. One is people saying this is a Chicago guy, he doesn't completely represent our values, he doesn't understand us.
BERKES: Glen Bolger is the Republican political consultant who supervised and analyzed the bipartisan survey, which included 600 rural voters in nine battleground states.
BOLGER: You know, he accused of being bitter by clinging to guns and religion four years ago, so we took a chance on him, he disappointed us, so we're going to go back to their more traditional voting patterns.
BERKES: That means big Republican numbers in rural counties, and the survey has Romney at 54 percent, a 14 point margin. That group includes Donald Young, a 66-year-old painter in Stevens Point, Wisconsin, who says he was forced into retirement by a weak economy.
DONALD YOUNG: Romney has a business background, so Romney will do something to create a friendly business climate, and these people will open up and start hiring and developing.
BERKES: The rural romp for Romney doesn't surprise Anna Greenberg, the Democratic pollster on the bipartisan survey team.
ANNA GREENBERG: I think this survey reinforces the overall geographic dynamics of elections in this country, which is to say big margins in urban areas for Democrats contesting the suburbs and losing rural areas big, but there's some things in the survey that are intriguing.
BERKES: Like this question: Who would do a better job of addressing the needs and concerns of women? It's the only question in the survey in which more respondents favored President Obama, and they did so by five points. That may help explain some indecision among some of the women polled. Erin Jordan is a 24-year-old nurse in Gallipolis, Ohio, who voted Republican four years ago, but says this about the president.
ERIN JORDAN: He's just more appealing to the general population. I mean even doing things like going on the late-night shows like Jimmy Fallon and doing the little rap thing that he did on there, it just makes him more approachable.
BERKES: And when Jordan thinks of Mitt Romney...
JORDAN: I picture my dad. My dad's not always firm in what he believes in politically, I guess.
BERKES: But Romney may get Jordan's vote, she says, because she's concerned as a nurse about changes in health care under President Obama and how that might change more if he's reelected. Still, this volatility encourages Democratic pollster Anna Greenberg.
GREENBERG: I actually think it's really possible that Obama picks up more support in rural areas, which just will bolster a growing lead, frankly.
BERKES: Well, there isn't much rural support up for grabs if the poll reflects reality. Just two percent of those surveyed didn't pick a favorite. Only three percent said they were just leaning toward a candidate. Mitt Romney seems to have the rural margin he needs to make him competitive in battleground states. Howard Berkes, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.