3:50pm

Mon July 9, 2012
It's All Politics

Swing State TV Stations Spiking Ad Rates As Campaign Cash Pours In

Originally published on Mon July 9, 2012 5:19 pm

Someone once said that owning a TV station is a license to print money. Now, that was before the advent of cable TV and computer screens and streaming video. But these are clearly good times for some stations, especially the ones in presidential battleground states.

While the November election is still four months away, President Obama, Republican Mitt Romney and outside groups are advertising in record amounts.

"If you are a television station in a media market in one of those handful of [swing] states, there's an incredible amount of demand for your inventory from political buyers," says Ken Goldstein of Kantar Media CMAG, which tracks political ad spending.

In Ohio, for example, TV viewers are being treated to lots of ads from Obama and Romney.

"Both presidential candidates are running [ads]. A variety of PACs and superPACs are running," explains Dan Bradley, president and general manager of NBC affiliate WCMH in Columbus, Ohio.

According to one media buying group that provided its figures to NPR, last week alone the Obama campaign and its outside supporters spent some $345,000 on TV ads in the Columbus market, while the Romney campaign and its supporters spent around $220,000.

With all that demand, prices will go up, says Bradley.

"It's a commodity business. And when there's a large demand on that commodity and a lot of people trying to buy the same thing, the natural forces of the market cause the price to rise," says Bradley.

Bradley wouldn't say how much ad rates at his station have risen.

Jane Peters, president of Media Management Services, a Columbus firm that buys TV time for a range of clients from car dealers to local garden centers, says she is telling those clients to expect to pay up to 50 percent more for TV time in the coming months.

"We usually spend about, oh, $6 [thousand] or $7,000 a week, like in Dayton Ohio," says Peters. "It'll look like we'll need about $10 [thousand] or $15,000, you know, just to make that same impact once we get into the political window. But we'll be pre-empted. It probably won't even run."

Those spots may get pre-empted by political ads whose buyers are willing to pay top dollar to ensure their spots are seen at key times, such as adjacent to the local news or on popular shows like Jeopardy.

Setting TV ad rates is a complex equation. Kantar Media's Ken Goldstein says what you pay depends on who you are.

"Part of political advertising is very highly regulated, and part of political advertising buying is absolutely the Wild West," he says.

The regulated part pertains to candidates for federal office like president or the U.S. Senate.

Within 60 days of an upcoming election, in accordance with Federal Communications Commission rules, presidential and Senate candidates have to be given the lowest rate the station has charged for a similar ad in the past year.

Outside groups, on the other hand, are charged whatever the market will bear. That's not likely to slow the deep-pocketed advocacy groups.

But local businesses, just like many TV viewers, will be glad when November has come and gone.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Melissa Block.

Presidential candidates and outside political groups are spending record amounts to get their message out this election year. While many viewers might wish all those ads would just go away, the spending is good news for TV stations and that's especially true for stations in swing states.

Here's NPR's Brian Naylor.

BRIAN NAYLOR, BYLINE: Someone once said that owning a TV station is a license to print money. Now that was before the advent of cable TV and computer screens and streaming video but these are clearly good times for some stations, especially the ones in presidential battleground states, says Ken Goldstein of Kantar Media CMAG, which tracks political ad spending.

KEN GOLDSTEIN: If you are a television station in a media market in one of those handful of states, there's an incredible amount of demand for your inventory from political buyers.

NAYLOR: Take Ohio, for example. TV viewers there are being treated to lots of ads like this one from President Obama.

(SOUNDBITE OF A POLITICAL AD)

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: Mitt Romney's companies were pioneers in outsourcing U.S. jobs to low-wage countries. He supports tax breaks for companies that ship jobs overseas.

NAYLOR: And this one from presumptive Republican nominee Mitt Romney.

(SOUNDBITE OF A POLITICAL AD)

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #2: Mitt Romney has a plan to get America working. Barack Obama, worst job record since the Depression.

NAYLOR: Dan Bradley is president and general manager of WCMH in Columbus, the NBC affiliate in Ohio's capital. He says there are many different political ads airing on his station.

DAN BRADLEY: Both presidential candidates are running, a variety of PACS and superPACs are running. And then, on top of all that, we have an interesting argument going on with the big power company.

NAYLOR: According to one media buying group that provided its figures to NPR, last week alone, the Obama campaign and its outside supporters spent some $345,000 on Columbus TV, the Romney campaign and its supporters around $220,000.

With all that demand, says WCMH's Bradley , prices will go up.

BRADLEY: It's a commodity business. And when there's a large demand on that commodity, and a lot of people trying to buy the same thing, the natural forces of the market cause the price to rise.

NAYLOR: Bradley wouldn't say how much ad rates at his station have risen. Jane Peters is president of Media Management Services, a Columbus firm which buys TV time for a range of clients from car dealers to local garden centers. Peters says she's telling those clients to expect to pay up to 50 percent more for TV time in the coming months.

JANE PETERS: We usually spend about, oh, six, $7,000 a week like in Dayton, Ohio. But it'll look like we'll need about 10 or 15,000, you know, just to make that same impact once we get into the political window. But we'll be preempted and we probably won't even run.

NAYLOR: Those spots may get preempted by political ads, whose buyers are willing to pay top dollar to ensure their spots are seen at key times, such as adjacent to the local news or on popular shows like "Jeopardy."

Setting TV ad rates is a complex equation. Kantar Media's Ken Goldstein says what you pay depends on who you are.

GOLDSTEIN: Part of political advertising is very highly regulated. And part of political advertising buying is absolutely the Wild West.

NAYLOR: The regulated part pertains to candidates for federal office like president or Senate. Within 60 days of the election, those candidates have to be given the lowest rate the station has charged for a similar ad in the past year.

Outside groups, on the other hand, are charged whatever the market will bear. That's not likely to slow the deep-pocketed advocacy groups. But local businesses, just like many TV viewers, will be glad when November has come and gone.

Brian Naylor, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related program: